Welcome to the forums. Please post in English or French.

You are not logged in.

Pages: 1

#1 2019-05-06 15:43:47

m_golbs
Member
From: Germany
Registered: 2009-11-09
Posts: 137

<EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hello,

I have a big model, with different AFFE_CARA_ELEM and different AFFE_MATERIAU. Also I have test element quality. No I get following error.

  ! <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1>                                                             !
   !                                                                                     !
   ! On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction (mot-clef TRACTION) dans le mat?riau fourni. !
   !                                                                                     !
   ! -                                                                                   !
   ! Contexte du message :                                                               !
   !    Option         : RIGI_MECA_TANG                                                  !
   !    Type d'?l?ment : MEDKTR3                                                         !
   !    Maillage       : NETZ                                                            !
   !    Maille         : M30474                                                          !
   !    Type de maille : TRIA3                                                           !
   !    Cette maille appartient aux groupes de mailles suivants :                        !
   !       EL2DPR01 ALLE2DEL EL2DTRIA                                                    !
   !    Position du centre de gravit? de la maille :                                     !
   !       x=1312.662005 y=665.706398 z=1507.902874                                      !
   !-!


   !-!
   ! <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1>                                                             !
   !                                                                                     !
   ! On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction (mot-clef TRACTION) dans le mat?riau fourni. !
   !                                                                                     !
   ! -                                                                                   !
   ! Contexte du message :                                                               !
   !    Option         : RIGI_MECA_TANG                                                  !
   !    Type d'?l?ment : MEDKTR3                                                         !
   !    Maillage       : NETZ                                                            !
   !    Maille         : M3004                                                           !
   !    Type de maille : TRIA3                                                           !
   !    Cette maille appartient aux groupes de mailles suivants :                        !
   !       EL2DPR01 ALLE2DEL EL2DTRIA ...                                                !
   !    Position du centre de gravit? de la maille :                                     !
   !       x=1019.073286 y=708.970468 z=37.550732                                        !
   !-!

The listed Maille are over all good mesh quality. Also only "0,1%" this elements in GROUP_MA="..." brings <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> the rest off 99,9% are correct.

Why brings only less elements in the GROUP_MA="..."  this "..traction (mot-clef TRACTION) dans le mat?riau fourni."? About informations I'm very happy.

Thanks Markus

The superfluous chase, is to miss the essential.
Jules Saliège

Offline

#2 2019-05-06 15:54:18

Voulet
Member
Registered: 2017-11-19
Posts: 28

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hallo.

I'm not sure about myself but:
Why do you think this is a mesh issue ?
Reading u4.43.01 §4.1.1, isn't the error message related to the TRACTION keyword of DEFI_MATERIAU ?

I read:
TRACTION = _F(SIGM =sigm_f),

Do you have defined any sigm_f fonction ?

I can translate:
  ! On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction (mot-clef TRACTION) dans le mat?riau fourni. !
to:
'We cannot find the traction curve (keyword TRACTION) of the given material."
if it can help.

Last edited by Voulet (2019-05-06 15:56:56)

Offline

#3 2019-05-06 15:58:28

m_golbs
Member
From: Germany
Registered: 2009-11-09
Posts: 137

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hello,

very thanks. My functions for material looks like:

S355Funk=DEFI_FONCTION(NOM_PARA='EPSI',
                       VALE=(0.00169 ,355.0 ,
                             0.08 ,500.0 ,
                             5.0 ,510.0 ,),
                       INTERPOL='LIN',
                       PROL_DROITE='LINEAIRE',
                       PROL_GAUCHE='EXCLU',);

S355=DEFI_MATERIAU(ELAS=_F(E=210000.0,
                           NU=0.3,
                           RHO=7.85e-09,),
                   TRACTION=_F(SIGM=S355Funk,),);

Is this a mistake? But why by so less elements?

Thanks Markus

The superfluous chase, is to miss the essential.
Jules Saliège

Offline

#4 2019-05-06 16:14:58

Voulet
Member
Registered: 2017-11-19
Posts: 28

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

S355Funk=DEFI_FONCTION(NOM_PARA='EPSI',
                       VALE=(0.00169 ,355.0 ,
                             0.08 ,500.0 ,
                             5.0 ,510.0 ,),
                       INTERPOL='LIN',
                       PROL_DROITE='LINEAIRE',
                       PROL_GAUCHE='EXCLU',);

Maybe the curve is not defined for epsi < 0.00169 because of PROL_GAUCHE = 'EXCLU' ?
Maybe these elements have a lower epsi ?

Offline

#5 2019-05-06 16:51:51

m_golbs
Member
From: Germany
Registered: 2009-11-09
Posts: 137

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hello,

very thanks. I dont understand the problem, because the rest of 99,9% in GROUP_MA('EL2DPR01','EL2DPR02','EL2DPR04',) are correct.

Maybe the curve is not defined for epsi < 0.00169 because of PROL_GAUCHE = 'EXCLU' ?

I think epsi < 0.00169 then ELAS definition works?

Thanks Markus

Last edited by m_golbs (2019-05-06 16:54:51)

Attachments:
20190506element30474.png, Size: 9.92 KiB, Downloads: 322

The superfluous chase, is to miss the essential.
Jules Saliège

Offline

#6 2019-05-06 17:02:07

jeanpierreaubry
Guru
From: nantes (france)
Registered: 2009-03-12
Posts: 3,986

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

hello

i would say that [as usual] the problem is probably not lying where one thinks it is at first
the .comm and mesh file would help to understand

jean pierre aubry

consider reading my book
freely available here https://framabook.org/beginning-with-code_aster/

Offline

#7 2019-05-06 17:29:33

m_golbs
Member
From: Germany
Registered: 2009-11-09
Posts: 137

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hallo

is it possible to use test alternativ? How works the ELAS sector on this end?

S355Funk=DEFI_FONCTION(NOM_PARA='EPSI',
                       VALE=(0.00169 ,355.0 ,
                             0.08 ,500.0 ,
                             5.0 ,510.0 ,),
                       INTERPOL='LIN',
                       PROL_GAUCHE='LINEAIRE',
                       PROL_DROITE='LINEAIRE',);
#                       PROL_GAUCHE='EXCLU',);

S355=DEFI_MATERIAU(ELAS=_F(E=210000.0,
                           NU=0.3,
                           RHO=7.85e-09,),
                   TRACTION=_F(SIGM=S355Funk,),);

Can I use DEFI_MATERIAU only with TRACTION function, without ELAS?

It is a big model with 20 AFFE_CARA_ELEM and 5 DEFI_MATERIAU 2D DKT, STAT_NON_LINE, PETIT_REAC, MPI .... I will try different employments.

[as usual] the problem is probably not lying where one thinks it is at first
the .comm and mesh file would help to understand..

Yes this is the correct way. But I think the *.comm is not the primary starting point. I have test the *comm with a big Modell only one DKT group,      equable CAD Modell >> equable mesh. It works all right.

How can I find problematic element quality with *.comm file implement?


Thanks Markus

Last edited by m_golbs (2019-05-06 17:46:14)

The superfluous chase, is to miss the essential.
Jules Saliège

Offline

#8 2019-05-06 18:04:40

jeanpierreaubry
Guru
From: nantes (france)
Registered: 2009-03-12
Posts: 3,986

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

How can I find problematic element quality with *.comm file implement?

looking at the message i am ready to bet this is not a quality problem
but more probably a problem of group assignement
but as i said only .comm and mesh file would help

It is a big model with 20 AFFE_CARA_ELEM and 5 DEFI_MATERIAU 2D DKT, STAT_NON_LINE, PETIT_REAC, MPI

i think i have already seen or made problem of that size or  complexity
i beleive i could understand it!

Can I use DEFI_MATERIAU only with TRACTION function, without ELAS?

i do ot think so

consider reading my book
freely available here https://framabook.org/beginning-with-code_aster/

Offline

#9 2019-05-09 13:55:18

m_golbs
Member
From: Germany
Registered: 2009-11-09
Posts: 137

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hallo,

many Thanks! The *.unv mesh file is nearly 100MB. It is a development project. I Cant post it complete. I have modify the last points of DEFI_FONCTION, upper "E-modul". Then I dont have the error "On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction (mot-clef TRACTION) dans le mat?riau fourni". It is not the absolut solution, but works now without this error.

i think i have already seen or made problem of that size or  complexity..

This is also my problem. Little models works, but big modells brings question. The project works fine with MECA_STATIQUE little depl, little stress/stains, also with STAT_NON_LINE without COMPORTEMENT= .. but with STAT_NON_LINE and COMPORTEMENT= I have a convergence offset.

    » STAT_NON_LINE basic convergence question



Thanks and greeting Markus

Last edited by m_golbs (2019-05-09 14:20:23)

Attachments:
20190509Fehlersuche.txt.gz, Size: 126.69 KiB, Downloads: 414

The superfluous chase, is to miss the essential.
Jules Saliège

Offline

#10 2019-05-09 15:48:08

jeanpierreaubry
Guru
From: nantes (france)
Registered: 2009-03-12
Posts: 3,986

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

STAT_NON_LINE without COMPORTEMENT= ..

what is the use of that?
i do not think this is allowed or it uses default values

consider reading my book
freely available here https://framabook.org/beginning-with-code_aster/

Offline

#11 2019-05-09 16:11:20

m_golbs
Member
From: Germany
Registered: 2009-11-09
Posts: 137

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hello,

many thanks! I wonder, that in u4.51.03 no information to COMPORTEMENT. Therefore the question to default in STAT_NON_LINE to the feature COMPORTEMENT. STAT_NON_LINE without COMPORTEMENT runs basically. 

   Total                              177785.81   16693.26  194479.07    5077.32
 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   (*) cpu and system times may be not correctly counted using mpirun.

as_run 2018.0

------------------------------------------------------------
--- DIAGNOSTIC JOB : <A>_ALARM
------------------------------------------------------------


EXIT_CODE=0

But under with conditions to come the results?

We have real test results by this project. STAT_NON_LINE with

...
...
KD2EVC=AFFE_MODELE(MAILLAGE=NETZ,
                    AFFE=(_F(TOUT='OUI',
                             PHENOMENE='MECANIQUE',
                             MODELISATION='3D',),
                          _F(GROUP_MA=('EL2DPR01','EL2DPR02','EL2DPR03','EL2DPR04','EL2DPR05','EL2DPR06','EL2DPR07','EL2DPR08',
                                        'EL2DPR09','EL2DPR10','EL2DPR11','EL2DPR12','EL2DPR13','EL2DPR14','EL2DPR15',
                                        'EL2DPR16','EL2DPR18','EL2DPR19','EL2DPR30','EL2DPR50',),
                             PHENOMENE='MECANIQUE',
                             MODELISATION='DKTG',),),);
..
..
..
S355Funk=DEFI_FONCTION(NOM_PARA='EPSI',
                       VALE=(0.00169 ,355.0 ,
                             0.08 ,500.0 ,
                             0.5 ,510.0 ,),
                       INTERPOL='LIN',
                       PROL_GAUCHE='LINEAIRE',
                       PROL_DROITE='LINEAIRE',);
#                       PROL_GAUCHE='EXCLU',);

S355=DEFI_MATERIAU(ELAS=_F(E=210000.0,
                           NU=0.3,
                           RHO=7.85e-09,),
                   TRACTION=_F(SIGM=S355Funk,),);
....
S420Funk...
S550Funk...
DC04Funk...
SG03Funk...
....
....

ERGEBNIS=STAT_NON_LINE(MODELE=KD2EVC,
                      CHAM_MATER=MATERIAL,
             	      CONTACT = KONTAKT,
                      CARA_ELEM=CARA,
                      EXCIT=(_F(CHARGE=LAGER01,
                                 TYPE_CHARGE='FIXE_CSTE',),
                              _F(CHARGE=Lastseit,
                                 FONC_MULT=Lastfunk,
                                 TYPE_CHARGE='FIXE_CSTE',),),
                        COMPORTEMENT=(_F(DEFORMATION='GROT_GDEP',
                                         RELATION='ELAS_VMIS_TRAC',
                                          TOUT='OUI',),
                                      _F(DEFORMATION='GROT_GDEP',
                                         GROUP_MA=('ALLE2DEL', ),
                                         RELATION='ELAS_VMIS_TRAC',),),
                       INCREMENT=_F(LIST_INST=SolSchrX,
                                    PRECISION=1e-06,),
                       METHODE='NEWTON',
#                       NEWTON=_F(MATRICE='ELASTIQUE',
#                       MATRICE='TANGENTE',
#                                 PREDICTION='EXTRAPOLE',),
#                                 PREDICTION='TANGENTE',
                       CONVERGENCE=_F(RESI_GLOB_MAXI=10,
#                                     RESI_GLOB_RELA=1e-06,
                                      ARRET='NON',
                                      ITER_GLOB_MAXI=25,),
                       SOLVEUR=_F(METHODE='MUMPS',
                                  RENUM='METIS',
                                  NPREC=12,
                                  ELIM_LAGR='NON',
                                  STOP_SINGULIER='NON',),
                       ARCHIVAGE=_F(LIST_INST=ArcSchri,
                                    CRITERE='RELATIF',
                                    PRECISION=1e-06,),);

bring only 5% of real test fail force. In my the code is also an error, but where? I think my mistake located in COMPORTEMENT, possibly in DEFI_MATERIAU...

Thanks and greeting Markus

Last edited by m_golbs (2019-05-09 17:30:39)

The superfluous chase, is to miss the essential.
Jules Saliège

Offline

#12 2019-05-12 12:29:36

FEUser
Member
Registered: 2019-04-27
Posts: 2

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hi Markus,

Did your Problem get solved? I have exactly the same Problem...
I tried to remesh and tried other Things. So far no success.
Any help would be great.

Cheers,
FEUser

Offline

#13 2019-05-13 09:04:53

m_golbs
Member
From: Germany
Registered: 2009-11-09
Posts: 137

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hello,

unfortunately no. Next I will Mr. jeanpierreaubry hint test "..but more probably a problem of group assignement.."

TL61GRA3=AFFE_MODELE(MAILLAGE=NETZ,
                    INFO=1,
                    VERI_JACOBIEN='OUI',
                    DISTRIBUTION=_F(METHODE='CENTRALISE',),
                    AFFE=(_F(TOUT='OUI',
                             PHENOMENE='MECANIQUE',
                             MODELISATION='3D',),
                          _F(GROUP_MA=('EL2DPR01','EL2DPR02','EL2DPR03','EL2DPR04','EL2DPR05','EL2DPR06','EL2DPR07','EL2DPR08',
                                        'EL2DPR09','EL2DPR10','EL2DPR11','EL2DPR12','EL2DPR13','EL2DPR14','EL2DPR15',
                                        'EL2DPR16','EL2DPR18','EL2DPR19','EL2DPR30','EL2DPR50',),
                             PHENOMENE='MECANIQUE',
                             MODELISATION='COQUE_3D',),),);

name definition of groups
EL: Elements  (NO for nodes,..)
2D: Typ of dimension
PR: properties ( thickness >> material...)
01: consecutive number


Means "..but more probably a problem of group assignement.." that are one element in two groups and so on...?

Thanks and greeting Markus

The superfluous chase, is to miss the essential.
Jules Saliège

Offline

#14 2020-07-06 21:59:22

Duc Vu
Member
Registered: 2020-04-03
Posts: 41

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hi all,

Did anyone got problem resolved? I got the same error when I'm trying to simulate the contact between the cylinder and a concrete beam under the direct shear test. I assigned all the metal cylinder by elasto-plastic material (COMPORTEMENT = 'VMIS_ISOT_TRAC') and I got this error. The model with elastical material ran very well.
I join here the .comm file and the meshes.

Thanks.

Attachments:
direct_shear.zip, Size: 38.03 KiB, Downloads: 358

Offline

#15 2020-07-07 05:43:33

AsterO'dactyle
Administrator
Registered: 2007-11-29
Posts: 456

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

hello,

you didn't affect traction curve on the concrete

Code_Asterの開発者

Offline

#16 2020-07-09 00:42:12

Duc Vu
Member
Registered: 2020-04-03
Posts: 41

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hello,

Thank for your reply, but I want that there is only cylinder (steel) is affected by the elasto-plastical behavior, the beam in concrete still work in elastic. So how can I do that?

Thanks.

Offline

#17 2020-07-09 05:43:21

konyaro
Member
From: Genève
Registered: 2016-04-02
Posts: 272

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Hello,
you must add the 2 behaviors in STAT_NON_LINE:

COMPORTEMENT=(_F(GROUP_MA=('steel'),
                 RELATION='VMIS_ISOT_TRAC'),
              _F(GROUP_MA=('concr'),
                 RELATION='ELAS')),

Konyaro

Last edited by konyaro (2020-07-09 05:43:39)

失敗は成功のもと (L'échec est la base de la réussite)

Offline

#18 2020-07-10 12:34:02

Duc Vu
Member
Registered: 2020-04-03
Posts: 41

Re: <EXCEPTION> <COMPOR5_1> On ne trouve pas la courbe de traction

Oh well, I didn't paid attention on that, now it works. That great!
Thank you a lot.

Offline

Pages: 1